When We Were Magic
by Sarah Gailey
Age rating: Ages 15+ · Young Adults
Age rating and Christian content guidance for parents.
Five sisters discover they are witches and must learn to control their powers while navigating family dynamics and a looming threat.
Concern Level
Extreme
Virtue Level
Present
Concern Level
Extreme
Virtue Level
Present
What is Dokilit?
Dokilit is an AI-powered content guide for Christian parents. We analyse books through the lens of faith and family, then show you the concerns, the virtues, and the conversation points that matter for your home.
Things to consider
Higher = more presentRomantic relationships and kissing are present among characters.
Some minor conflict and magical duels occur.
No profanity is used by the characters.
No blasphemous content is included.
No substance abuse is a theme in this book.
No suicide or self-harm is depicted.
Some suspenseful moments and magical threats exist.
Witchcraft and magical abilities are central to the plot and characters.
No LGBTQ+ themes are present in the narrative.
The story does not promote a non-Christian worldview.
No negative portrayals of God or Christians are present.
Virtues to celebrate
Higher = stronger presenceThe sisters show courage in protecting each other and mastering their powers.
Christian faith is not a theme in this book.
Sisterly love and familial bonds are a primary focus.
Themes of responsibility and facing challenges are explored.
We may earn a small commission from purchases — it never influences scores.
Comments
Loading comments…