Christian book reviews for parents

Back to results
The Magicians (The Magicians, #1) cover
Young Adults · Ages 17+

The Magicians (The Magicians, #1)

by Lev Grossman

Age rating: Ages 17+ · Young Adults

Age rating and Christian content guidance for parents.

First published 2009

Quentin Coldwater is recruited into a secret college for magic, only to discover that the whimsical land of his childhood books is real and far more dangerous than he imagined.

Concern Level

93/ 100

Extreme

Virtue Level

17/ 100

Thin

What is Dokilit?

Dokilit is an AI-powered content guide for Christian parents. We analyse books through the lens of faith and family, then show you the concerns, the virtues, and the conversation points that matter for your home.

Learn more about Dokilit

Things to consider

Sexual Content65

Characters engage in multiple on-page sexual encounters, including a scene involving magical transformation.

Violence / Gore75

Graphic violence occurs, including a brutal attack by an entity that results in dismemberment.

Profanity / Language85

Strong profanity, including frequent use of the F-word, is used throughout the dialogue.

Blasphemy40

Characters frequently use God's name as an exclamation and express cynical views toward divinity.

Substance Use80

Heavy drinking and recreational drug use are common among the students at Brakebills.

Suicide & Self-Harm60

The story heavily features clinical depression, nihilism, and characters struggling with a lack of purpose.

Scary / Disturbing70

The Beast is a terrifying antagonist, and several scenes involve intense psychological and physical horror.

Occult & Witchcraft90

Magic is portrayed as a difficult, academic, and often dangerous craft involving complex rituals.

Sexuality & Gender Themes40

The book includes secondary characters who are gay and mentions of same-sex attraction.

Worldview & Spirituality95

The story promotes a deeply nihilistic worldview where magic cannot provide meaning or happiness.

Anti-God or Christian Portrayal30

While not targeting the Church, the book deconstructs and mocks traditional moral allegories like Narnia.

Virtues to celebrate

Courage & Sacrifice30

Characters occasionally act bravely, but actions are often driven by boredom or desperation.

Faith & Hope5

The story is set in a secular, disenchanted world where traditional religious faith is absent.

Love & Friendship25

Romantic relationships are largely depicted as dysfunctional, selfish, or fleeting.

Forgiveness & Redemption20

Characters struggle with resentment and rarely find true path to reconciliation or grace.

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission from purchases — it never influences scores.

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment.

Loading comments…