Christian book reviews for parents

Back to results
The Catskill witch and other tales of the Hudson Valley cover
Young Adults · Ages 14–17

The Catskill witch and other tales of the Hudson Valley

by James McMurry

Age rating: Ages 14–17 · Young Adults

Age rating and Christian content guidance for parents.

First published 1974

This collection presents various tales from the Hudson Valley, including one about a witch.

Concern Level

52/ 100

Heavy

Virtue Level

4/ 100

Thin

What is Dokilit?

Dokilit is an AI-powered content guide for Christian parents. We analyse books through the lens of faith and family, then show you the concerns, the virtues, and the conversation points that matter for your home.

Learn more about Dokilit

Things to consider

Sexual Content0

No sexual content is present in these stories.

Violence / Gore15

Some tales may contain mild peril or unsettling events.

Profanity / Language0

Profanity is absent from the stories.

Blasphemy0

No blasphemous language is used.

Substance Use0

Substance use is not depicted.

Suicide & Self-Harm0

The stories do not feature suicide or self-harm.

Scary / Disturbing30

Some stories, particularly the witch tale, may be spooky.

Occult & Witchcraft60

The 'Catskill Witch' story explicitly features witchcraft.

Sexuality & Gender Themes0

No LGBTQ+ themes or characters are featured.

Worldview & Spirituality40

The presence of witchcraft and folklore may conflict with a Christian worldview.

Anti-God or Christian Portrayal0

God and Christians are not portrayed negatively.

Virtues to celebrate

Courage & Sacrifice10

Characters may show bravery against supernatural elements.

Faith & Hope0

Christian faith is absent from these tales.

Love & Friendship5

Interactions are minimal and not focused on love.

Forgiveness & Redemption5

Themes are primarily folklore and supernatural events.

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission from purchases — it never influences scores.

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment.

Loading comments…