Christian book reviews for parents

Back to results
One of Us Is Lying (One of Us is Lying, #1) cover
Young Adults · Ages 15–17

One of Us Is Lying (One of Us is Lying, #1)

by Karen M. McManus

Age rating: Ages 15–17 · Young Adults

Age rating and Christian content guidance for parents.

Five students enter detention, but only four come out alive, leaving the survivors as prime suspects in a high-profile murder investigation.

Concern Level

62/ 100

Heavy

Virtue Level

26/ 100

Present

What is Dokilit?

Dokilit is an AI-powered content guide for Christian parents. We analyse books through the lens of faith and family, then show you the concerns, the virtues, and the conversation points that matter for your home.

Learn more about Dokilit

Things to consider

Sexual Content35

Characters engage in heavy making out and there are references to past sexual encounters.

Violence / Gore40

The plot centers on a fatal allergic reaction and includes descriptions of physical altercations.

Profanity / Language65

Frequent use of strong language including the f-word, s-word, and various other profanities.

Blasphemy30

The Lord's name is used casually as an exclamation throughout the story.

Substance Use45

Underage drinking, drug dealing, and the misuse of prescription medication are significant plot points.

Suicide & Self-Harm60

The story involves themes of depression and a character's detailed plan for self-harm.

Scary / Disturbing30

The tension of being a murder suspect and the threat of exposure creates a suspenseful atmosphere.

Occult & Witchcraft0

There are no occult or supernatural elements in this contemporary mystery.

Sexuality & Gender Themes40

A main character struggles with their sexual identity and eventually comes out as gay.

Worldview & Spirituality50

The narrative focuses on moral relativism and the pressure to maintain false public images.

Anti-God or Christian Portrayal10

Religion is largely absent, though some characters display cynical attitudes toward traditional morality.

Virtues to celebrate

Courage & Sacrifice45

The protagonists eventually show bravery by telling the truth despite the personal cost.

Faith & Hope5

There is no mention of Christian faith or reliance on God by the characters.

Love & Friendship45

The protagonists develop supportive friendships and navigate complicated family dynamics.

Forgiveness & Redemption35

Characters seek reconciliation with family and peers after their secrets are revealed.

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission from purchases — it never influences scores.

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment.

Loading comments…