
If He Had Been With Me (If He Had Been with Me, #1)
by Laura Nowlin
Age rating: Ages 15+ · Young Adults
Age rating and Christian content guidance for parents.
First published 2013
Autumn and Finny have been inseparable since birth, but a high school rift leaves them navigating separate lives until a tragic accident changes everything.
Concern Level
Heavy
Virtue Level
Present
Concern Level
Heavy
Virtue Level
Present
What is Dokilit?
Dokilit is an AI-powered content guide for Christian parents. We analyse books through the lens of faith and family, then show you the concerns, the virtues, and the conversation points that matter for your home.
Things to consider
Higher = more presentThe story includes detailed descriptions of making out and a significant off-page sexual encounter.
The story centers on a fatal car accident, though the physical impact is not graphic.
Frequent use of strong language including the F-word and other common profanities throughout.
Characters occasionally use the Lord's name as an exclamation or in casual frustration.
High school characters engage in underage drinking and recreational marijuana use at parties.
Autumn struggles with significant depression and there are references to self-harm and suicidal ideation.
The emotional weight of the ending is heavy, but there is no horror content.
There are no occult or supernatural elements in this realistic fiction novel.
A secondary character is mentioned as being gay, but it is not a primary focus.
The story prioritizes emotional fulfillment and 'what if' regrets over objective moral frameworks.
Christianity is largely absent and ignored rather than being actively mocked or attacked.
Virtues to celebrate
Higher = stronger presenceAutumn shows some emotional resilience while navigating the social pressures of high school life.
There is no mention of Christian faith or reliance on God during trials.
The book explores deep emotional bonds and the complexities of long-term friendship and family.
Characters attempt to reconcile past misunderstandings, though true repentance is not a central theme.
We may earn a small commission from purchases — it never influences scores.
Comments
Loading comments…